Read & Listen · Audiobooks · The Monthly All-Hands· Official finding

September 2026 Audiobooks: The Hits (and One Miss)

What went through the earbuds this month, which ones earned the Audible credit, and one that's been placed on a performance plan.

Executive summary

September’s listening has been reviewed by leadership (me). Results are in: one strong performer, one solid contributor, and one high-profile hire that didn’t live up to the interview. Every Audible credit was accounted for.

  1. 1

    The Unselected Journals of Emma M. Lion, Vol. 82

    Beth Brower · Narrated by Genevieve Gaunt · 12h 18m

    4/5 · Exceeds Expectations

    Key Value-AddsEmma's voice is the whole show: sharp, funny and completely herself, and Genevieve Gaunt nails it. Add the humor and Stonecrop, and eight volumes in it still delivers.

    Not a Fit ForAnyone who needs closure. The series isn't done, so you'll finish Vol. 8 wanting the next one now. New here? Start at Vol. 1.

  2. 2

    Theo of Golden

    Allen Levi · Narrated by David Morse · 13h 12m

    3/5 · Meets Expectations

    Key Value-AddsGenuinely heartwarming. You finish it wanting to move somewhere small and know everyone at the coffee shop by name.

    Not a Fit ForAnyone who needs momentum. The writing and the story take their time, so it's a slow walk, not a page-turner.

  3. 3

    Piranesi3PIP

    Susanna Clarke · Narrated by Chiwetel Ejiofor

    2/5 · Needs Improvement

    Key Value-AddsIt starts genuinely intriguing: a strange, endless house and a narrator you want to figure out. If slow, dreamy, atmospheric puzzles are your thing, you may see what everyone else sees.

    Not a Fit ForAnyone hoping to be surprised. Once the mystery clicks into place, you'll see where it's going well before it gets there. Predictable, and honestly a little meh.

Action items

Got one credit? Spend it on Emma M. Lion (start at Vol. 1). Need something cozy for slow evenings? Theo of Golden. Piranesi can wait for its performance review.

Footnotes

  1. Source: me.
  2. Bonus withheld pending series completion.
  3. Placed on a Performance Improvement Plan. The hype has 90 days to justify itself.

Some links on this page may earn a small commission. It never changes the ranking.